Editorial and Reviewer Responsibilities
Editors and reviewers of the journal must uphold scientific integrity, fairness, confidentiality, independence, and transparency.
Responsibilities of editors
Editors must:
- Protect editorial independence
- Evaluate manuscripts fairly
- Select appropriately qualified reviewers
- Maintain confidentiality
- Identify and manage conflicts of interest
- Assess reviewer reports critically
- Protect research participants
- Investigate credible misconduct allegations
- Correct the scholarly record when necessary
- Prevent commercial considerations from influencing decisions
- Maintain transparent editorial documentation
Editors must recuse themselves when they have significant personal, academic, institutional, professional, or financial conflicts of interest.
Responsibilities of reviewers
Reviewers must:
- Accept assignments only within their expertise
- Provide timely and objective reviews
- Maintain confidentiality
- Declare conflicts of interest
- Provide evidence-based criticism
- Avoid abusive or discriminatory language
- Identify ethical or research-integrity concerns
- Protect unpublished ideas and data
- Avoid coercive citations.
- Follow journal policies regarding artificial intelligence.
Responsibilities of the Editor-in-Chief
The Editor-in-Chief safeguards the scientific direction, editorial standards, integrity, independence, and academic reputation of the journal.
The Editor-in-Chief may reopen or review an editorial decision where substantial evidence of procedural error, inadequate peer review, ethical problems, or research-integrity concerns is identified.