The journal provides authors, reviewers, readers, and other stakeholders with a transparent process for submitting editorial appeals and complaints.

Editorial appeals

Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they believe that a substantial factual, scientific, or procedural error materially affected the decision.

An appeal should:

  • Identify the manuscript.
  • Clearly explain the grounds for appeal.
  • Address the specific scientific or procedural issue.
  • Provide supporting evidence where relevant.

Disagreement with an editorial decision or reviewer opinion alone does not automatically constitute valid grounds for appeal.

Where possible, appeals will be assessed by a senior editor who was not directly responsible for the original disputed decision.

Complaints

Complaints may relate to:

  • Editorial procedures
  • Peer-review conduct
  • Publication ethics
  • Conflicts of interest
  • Excessive delays
  • Staff conduct
  • Published content
  • Journal policies
  • Publisher conduct

Complaints are handled confidentially, objectively, and proportionately.

Individuals raising concerns in good faith will not face disadvantages solely because they submitted a complaint.

An appropriate independent representative of the journal or publisher should handle complaints involving the Editor-in-Chief.